For our BSc module Smart solutions for sustainable cities two groups of students performed two separate thermal walks this winter in the same locations as our previous students did last summer. On the first day in December it was still quite warm with afternoon temperatures reaching up to 15 degrees Celsius, whereas the second day was right after heavy snowfall had cleared on 13 January. While it was colder with 9 degrees Celsius, people experienced the day as relatively comfortable, but this could be due to it being less cold than the days before.
The most important conclusions were that thermal walks were possible and relevant in winter. There should be a higher emphasis on the perceived temperatures as this proved to be more unrelated to external factors than in summer. Also, while in summer temperature and solar radiation were the main weather factors affecting comfort, in winter wind and humidity/precipitation were much more influential. Other differences are found in the table below.
Only denser vegetation had some impact on reducing wind speed, and most urban green infrastructure was too sparse to impact this. However, denser green infrastructure could block more solar radiation and thereby reduce thermal comfort. A balance between these two factors needs to be found when UGI is designed, not just for summer, but for year round thermal comfort.























